His head tilts a little, dark brown eyes searching her face like he could gain some additional context on that alone. He couldn't.

"That mean you're a witch or somethin'?"

It was the most logical jump and poor mundo man that he was, was only just learning just how deep the pool of the multiverse went. There was no judgement in the question, no subtle fearful tension about it - if she was a witch and she wanted to do him harm, she would have already.